从定性角度论客观试题效度检验On the Validation of Objective Tests from the Qualitative Perspective
陈晓扣
摘要(Abstract)：
效度历尽七十余年的发展已演变成一个整体概念,但是从方法论角度看,目前绝大多数效度实证研究依然只是单纯地使用定量研究方法收集"构念"相关证据,忽略了"构念"理论检验和内容相关证据在效度检验中的重要性和价值,从而无法体现效度整体观的本质。另一方面,客观试题由于自身的局限性,其效度也长期饱受争议。针对上述两个问题,本文从定性角度重点讨论如何创建一个反映效度整体观的客观试题效度检验模型,以期更好地指导客观试题的效度检验。
关键词(KeyWords)： 效度;客观试题;定性研究;检验模型
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): 陈晓扣
参考文献(References)：
- [1]American Psychological Association,American Educational Research Association,& National Council on Measurement in Education. Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing[Z].Washington, DC:American Psychological Association,1999.
- [2]Bachman,L.F.Fundamental Considerations in Language Testing [M].Oxford:Oxford University Press,1990.
- [3]Bachman,L.F.Statistical Analysis for Language Assessment[M]. Cambridge:Cambridge University press,2004.
- [4]Bachman,L.F.& Cohen A.D.Interfaces between Second Language Acquisition and Language Testing Research[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1999.
- [5]Cronbach,L.J.,& Meehl,P.E.Construct validity in psychological tests[J].Psychological Bulletin,1955,52:281-302.
- [6]Heaton,J.B.Writing English Language Test[M].Harlow:Longman, 1988.
- [7]Kane,M.T.Validating high-stakes testing programs[J].Educational Measurement:Issues and Practices,2002.
- [8]Klein-Braley,C.Empirical Investigation of Cloze Tests:an Examination of the Validity of Cloze Tests as Tests of General Language Proficiency in English for German University Students[D].Unpublished Ph.D.dissertation.University of Duisburg,1981.
- [9]Krista,V.Quantitative and qualitative methods of construction in language assessment:conflict or synergy[J].Journal of Quantitative Linguists, 1998,5(12):105-114.
- [10]Linn,R.L.& Gronlund,N.E.Measurement and Assessment in Teaching(8~(th)ed.)[M].Upper Saddle River,NJ:Prentice-Hall, 2000.
- [11]Messick,S.A.The once and future issues of validity:assessing the meaning and consequences of measurement[A].In H.Wainer and H.I.Braun(eds.),Test validity[C].Hillsdale,NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum, 1988.
- [12]Messick,S.A.Validity[A].In R.L.Linn(ed.),Educational Measurement(3~(rd) ed.,13-103)[C].New York:American Council on Education,Macmillan Publishing company,1989.
- [13]陈晓扣.TEM-4客观试题效度研究[M].上海:复旦大学出版社, 2009.
- [14]陈晓扣,李绍山.谈语言测试的结构效度[J].解放军外国语学报(3),2006.